Why Your First Raised Paddle Changes Everything

Hello, fabulous fundraisers!

This insightful post was generously provided by Samantha Swaim from Swaim Strategies, a friend of Artisan Auctions and an excellent resource for nonprofit leaders looking to take their fundraising game to the next level. Special thanks to Samantha for sharing her expertise into the science behind the paddle raise—a critical moment at any event that can make or break your fundraiser. But as Samantha explains, there are better ways to pull off your paddle raise than simply hoping a donor starts the giving. With the right preparation, you can ensure your paddle raise will be a success before the event begins.

---

There's a psychological pivot point at every gala—that split-second when someone raises their hand to bid. In that instant, the entire room recalibrates. What was once a question ("Should I participate?") becomes an assumption ("Of course I'm participating").

This isn't random. It's neuroscience.

The Science Behind Collective Action

When people witness others committing to something meaningful, their brains shift into alignment mode. They stop calculating risk and start asking: "How do I join what's already happening?"

This is the foundation of all movements. The first brave soul who takes action doesn't become the hero—they become the permission slip for everyone else.

Your paddle raise taps directly into this wiring. The first few hands in the air don't just represent donations. They represent invitation, safety, and proof that this cause deserves major support.

Building Your Unstoppable Sequence

To activate this psychological momentum, you need three strategic layers:

Anchor with intention. Before guests arrive, secure one substantial commitment at your highest giving level. This establishes your North Star and sets expectations for what's possible. Your lead donor becomes the catalyst—the person who demonstrates bold action first.

Create the wave. Lock in at least three additional commitments in your top two giving brackets before the event begins. These gifts do crucial psychological work. They prove the first gift wasn't an outlier. They normalize giving at significant levels. They turn possibility into inevitability.

Remove friction. Deploy a matching gift opportunity during your appeal. When donors know their contribution amplifies impact, participation feels less like risk and more like smart strategy. The barrier to saying yes drops dramatically.

Watch It Unfold

See how real-time energy compounds as paddles rise in sync:

Notice how momentum builds. Notice how the question shifts from "Do I give?" to "At what level do I give?"

Beyond Your Ballroom

The power of collective participation extends beyond in-person gatherings. When hybrid audiences witness the thermometer climbing in real time—seeing both in-room and virtual gifts stacking up—they experience the same belonging. They're not clicking to make a transaction. They're clicking to join a surge.

The Lasting Impact

Galas that master this psychology do something remarkable: they convert one-time donors into long-term champions. When people feel they've joined something bigger than themselves—rather than simply written a check—their relationship with your mission fundamentally shifts.

This is the difference between a successful fundraising evening and a fundraising movement. And it starts with understanding that your job isn't to ask harder. It's to create the conditions where saying yes feels like joining.

Paddle Raise FAQ

Q: What is a paddle raise?

A: A paddle raise is a live fundraising moment during a gala or event where supporters physically raise bid paddles to make a direct cash donation. It is an active form of donation collection. 

Q: Why does the first paddle raise matter so much?

A: That first raised paddle is a permission signal. This first action activates a psychological principle that is an invitation to participate.

Q: How do you build momentum before the event even starts?

A: Strategic pre-event work creates the foundation for in-room momentum. Secure one substantial lead gift at your highest level to establish what's possible. Then lock in at least three additional commitments in your top two giving brackets. This creates a tipping point.

Q: What is a matching gift?

A: A matching gift is a commitment from a donor or sponsor to match (dollar-for-dollar or by a multiplier like 2:1 or 3:1) the donations made by other supporters during a specific fundraising moment or event. When an organization announces a matching gift during a paddle raise, it means every dollar raised will be doubled, tripled, or multiplied by those pre-committed funds. Matching gifts function as psychological accelerators—they lower the barrier to giving by amplifying impact, making donors feel their contribution goes further, and creating urgency and momentum as people see their gifts being multiplied in real time.

Ready to create your own movement moment? It's time to talk to your major donors and set yourself up for success with pre-committed gifts. Learn more with this deep dive: Paddle Raise Strategy Podcast

Content provided by our partners at: